
White cake with lychee liquor-flavored vanilla frosting, topped with fresh blackberries and mint leaves.
My mama just had her birthday, and the responsibility of making a cake fell to me and my sister. This was very important: we had to prove how much we loved her, compensating for our bad behavior the rest of the year. Birthday cakes made from scratch are interesting, because they’re kind of a measure of your love for someone- the more effort you put in, the more you care for them. After the holidays, we were all pretty tired of sweets, but this cake was important. It had to say, “We love you, Mother. You really ARE the best mother anyone has ever had… just like you tell us every day.”
I had the idea of a very light white cake with a liquor-flavored vanilla frosting. My mom’s obsessed with this lychee liquor that she has -although she gets Asian glow and doesn’t really drink- so I wanted to use that in the frosting. Blackberries were on sale, and there was some fresh mint in the fridge, so that’s how we decorated the cake.
My sister Sienna thought this should be called the Lysander cake, since it looked like something out of A Midsummer Night’s Dream.

This is actually the first white cake I’ve ever made from scratch (chocolate is usually the go-to). Sienna found this recipe online. We chose this particular one, because we, too, are really light and fancy.
Like most cake recipes, this one has you sift the dry ingredients together, cream together the butter and sugar, and then add the dry ingredients to the butter alternately with milk. This one also calls for an extra step- creating a meringue by beating egg whites and sugar into stiff peaks, and adding this to the batter at the last minute. Meringues can be tricky, and I’ve definitely had them fail on me before, refusing to form peaks. It isn’t fun.

To make successful meringue, be extremely careful when separating your egg whites from the yolks- don’t let any yolk escape into the whites, at all. After separating out your whites, let them sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes before beating. The mixing bowl (metal or glass is best) and beaters should be completely clean and totally dry- wash and dry in preparation, if necessary. If you want to be extra cautious, chill your bowl and beaters in the fridge before using.
We didn’t have cake flour (who does?), so we substituted 2-1/2 cups regular flour and 1/3 cup cornstarch for the 2-3/4 cups cake flour in the recipe. [The substitution for 2 cups of cake flour is about 1-3/4 cups regular flour and 1/4 cup cornstarch.]
Use an electric mixer for this recipe. Making meringue by hand isn’t impossible, but why bother?
Finally, the most important thing about making a cake is not to overbake. After years of cake baking, I’ve realized this is crucial. Dry cake is not only hard to swallow, it’s disappointing! Even the best of frostings can’t disguise an overbaked cake.
-So, as your cake begins to rise up and look done, watch it like a hawk. Whisk it out of the oven the minute it looks done and prick it with a fork. If the fork comes out clean, without wet cake batter, let the cake cool immediately, leaving it in its pan. The heat from the pan will continue to bake the cake slightly longer. Basically, you want to remove the cake the minute it’s baked through, and let it finish cooking while cooling on the counter for a few minutes. For this recipe, which says the cake will take about 30-35 minutes, start hovering in front of the oven door around 28 minutes. Hint- a cake layer that’s baked through will have a rounded top- any indenting in the middle indicates wet batter is still present.
-If tragedy strikes and you think your cake is slightly overdone, tip the layers out of their pans onto plates and stick them in the fridge right away. The cold air should hopefully help the cake stop baking.
For the vanilla frosting, we used the best recipe ever, from Rachel Thebault’s Sweet Chic. You can add up to 1/2 cup liquor to a batch of frosting this large, and we added exactly that. Other liquors to try would be Grand Marnier, Chambord, creme de menthe, basically anything alcoholic. Leave your butter out for an hour or so to get it to room temperature. If you’re in a hurry, microwave butter in short bursts of about 8 seconds until soft- being careful not to let it melt, at all.
Frosting Ingredients
3 sticks [3/4 lb] unsalted sweet cream butter, at room temperature
4-1/2 cups confectioners sugar
2 tbsp milk
2 tbsp vanilla extract
1/2 cup lychee liquor [We used Soho]
*We scaled down the recipe from the original proportions: 4 sticks [1 lb] butter, 6 cups sugar, 2 tbsp milk, and 2 tbsp vanilla extract. The original just makes a ridiculous amount of frosting.
Frosting Directions
Using an electric mixer or wire whisk, cream butter. Mix in sugar a cupful at a time until incorporated; it will be pasty. Beat in milk, vanilla, and liquor.
Now, frost your cake using a cake spatula. If the tops of your cake layers are rounded, use a sharp knife or piece of dental floss to trim them flat. Place your bottom layer on your cake stand or serving plate and frost the top; place your top layer on it and frost its top. Next frost the sides. We decorated by pressing the mint leaves and blackberries in concentric circles.

The finished product! Sienna found the candelabra.
Mama’s only objection was that the frosting was too alcoholic and she was afraid of getting drunk. Sorry, Mama!